@diosmosis opened this Issue on July 30th 2015 Member

Currently the UI frontend will structure URLs like this:


This is ok for now since we don't use angular for URL parsing, however it won't be helpful later on. Using $location.search() with such a URL will return an empty object, since there is no '?' in the hash. Angular treats the string as a path instead of a query string.

URLs should look like this:


Changing this may cause problems w/ the historyService, would need to test (though UI tests should cover it).

@tsteur commented on July 30th 2015 Member

FYI: This is already implemented in #8442 for same reason.

It will be ...#?...

@diosmosis commented on July 30th 2015 Member

Can this be put into 2.15? It would be useful for a plugin I'm working on.

I assume BC for URLs might be an issue, right? I think the history service might take care of that automatically, but not sure.

@tsteur commented on July 31st 2015 Member

BC for URLs should not be an issue for the Piwik reporting UI itself (for exported widgets etc it is an issue but this one doesn't affect them).

The PR cannot be put into 2.15, there are several breaking API changes. There were also various problems with those URL changes starting from UI tests to overlay to ... and there were code changes needed in various places. I reckon it would be easier to work with broadcast for now. I had to create a service to access $location.search() anyway (see https://github.com/piwik/piwik/pull/8442/files#diff-a9b4a06fd105d04eaf7fb97abade0dd4R1) which might accesses broadcast again as there are some issues with $location.search:

Eg when having period=day&period=year angular would otherwise return ['day', 'year'] instead of 'year'


$location.search() returns empty when query params are not preceded by hash see https://github.com/angular/angular.js/issues/7239

What does it mean? When you have a URL like index.php?module=action&action=test you cannot get the value with $location.search('module'). We have a lot of such URLs... it should be index.php?module=action&action=test as well. We could change this behaviour I think be enabling HTML5 URL mode but then we would always have to test things with a browser that supports HTML 5 mode and with a browser that doesn't. I'm not exactly sure which browser support HTML 5 mode but IE 8 doesn't which should be still supported in 2.15.

@tsteur commented on August 20th 2015 Member

fixed via #8442

This Issue was closed on August 20th 2015
Powered by GitHub Issue Mirror