@mattab opened this Issue on February 22nd 2012 Member

Reported in forum:

Rather than failing with error message "timezone not valid"

  • we should display a proper error message "User does not have privilege"
  • update the requirement documentation to detail which privileges are required

Problem in code:

This issue arises from a call to Piwik_SetOption (when it's called from setDefaultTimezone) that causes an exception to be thrown because the public function "set" in Option.php fails at it's database call. This is due to insufficient database user privileges. Granting the piwik DB user more privileges allows the setup to continue.

Maybe we could have a page that checks the database user grants before continuing the setup. Or at-least some docs on the needed permissions for the piwik DB user since not everyone will be doing a "grant all".

@diosmosis commented on May 17th 2012 Member

Attachment: Patch for this issue.
2963.diff.tar.gz

@robocoder commented on February 27th 2012 Contributor

Checking the privileges by looking at SHOW GRANTS, or mysql.user and mysql.db tables, is non-trivial.

It would probably be easier (and more database-agnostic) to explicitly test the various operations used by Piwik, e.g.,

  • CREATE/ALTER, SELECT, INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE, etc
@diosmosis commented on May 17th 2012 Member

I uploaded a patch for this issue. This is the first time I've looked at the installation code, so I believe it would be good to review them.

Notes on the patch:

  • I use the strategy @vipsoft mentioned.
  • The check is provided as an extra form validation for the database setup page. If the user doesn't have the right privileges, a message displaying all the required privileges is displayed. As far as I can tell, its not possible to make a validation error message depend on the form values themselves, so that's as specific as it gets.

Let me know what you think.

@mattab commented on May 24th 2012 Member

Thanks vipsoft for the suggestion, and Kuddos capedfuzz for this clean patch!
Code review:

  • I would maybe detail the error a bit more in Installation_InsufficientPrivileges maybe you can add something along the lines of "You can use a tool such as phpMyAdmin (or a SQL query). If you do not know what this means, please ask your sysadmin to grant these privileges to the %s user".
  • TEST_TABLE_NAME and TEST_TEMP_TABLE_NAME couild be "piwik_test_table_tmp" and "piwik_test_table" just in case they're somehow left in there
  • can you confirm you checked individually each missing right and that the code works in all the cases? (I'm thinking in particular if the error codes in isAccessDenied() would cover all use cases of missing permissions)
@diosmosis commented on May 29th 2012 Member

(In [6371]) Fixes #2963, added installation check for needed DB user privileges.

@diosmosis commented on May 29th 2012 Member

Regarding my commit: I tested w/ every privilege, every needed privilege, w/ every needed privilege except one (for each privilege), and w/ no privileges. Also tested to make sure other fields were checked properly. Everything worked.

This Issue was closed on May 29th 2012
Powered by GitHub Issue Mirror